What a Leather Item Really Costs to Make: A Printable Worksheet

Leather Patterns / What a Leather Item Really Costs to Make: A Printable Worksheet
True Cost of a Leather Item: Marcellino NY leather bench tools title card over a photograph of leather work on a workbench
0 Comments

Seventy-five square inches, and a fraction. That is all the leather in the Marcellino NY bifold wallet pattern, counting every cut blank: the outer shell and four pockets. It is a little over half a square foot. At the worked example rate in Weaver Leather Supply’s costing guide, the leather in that wallet costs $7.81.

Video: Cutting Briefcase Panel from Natural Veg Tan Leather Side, from Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker on YouTube. Real bench footage of a panel cut from a side; it does not demonstrate the worksheet.

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 2

True Cost of a Leather Item: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · costing worksheet, leather area and cost of ten Marcellino NY patterns

A maker who prices that wallet by looking at a $280 side on the bench and feeling the weight of the purchase is pricing the wrong thing. The hide is far from the biggest line on the sheet; labor is. The free Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 2: True Cost of a Leather Item puts every line on one page, and its second page lists the leather in all ten patterns in the series, measured from the pattern files themselves.

Leather by the usable square foot

Weaver Leather Supply’s guide to pricing leather goods starts where the money starts. Its example side costs $250 plus $30 shipping, $280 delivered. The side measures about 22 square feet. Weaver allows about 15 percent waste on average, sometimes closer to 10, which leaves 18.7 usable square feet. Divide the price by the usable area, not the stamped area, and the leather costs $14.97 a usable square foot.

That one division is the whole trick. A side is sold by its outline, belly and flanks included, and nobody cuts a wallet from the belly. Pricing on the stamped 22 square feet quietly assumes every inch is good.

Other sources pad more. Tandy Leather’s buying guide adds 20 percent to cover imperfections, holes and loss in cutting. The upholstery trade goes further: one linear yard of 54 inch fabric is 13.5 square feet, but Kovi Fabrics explains that the industry specifies 18 square feet of leather in its place, because hides are irregular and not every inch is usable. That works out to a quarter of the purchase written off.

Here is what each allowance does to Weaver’s $280 side:

Waste allowedUsable sq ftRate per usable sq ftLeather in the bifold wallet
10%19.8$14.14$7.38
15% (Weaver)18.7$14.97$7.81
20% (Tandy)17.6$15.91$8.30
25% (upholstery rule)16.5$16.97$8.85

Arguing over the waste percentage is worth about a dollar on a wallet. Weaver’s own advice is the better fix: save the scrap from each hide and weigh it, so the number comes from the bench and not from a guide.

The leather in ten real patterns

Page 2 of the PDF lists the cut-blank area of every Marcellino NY pattern pack. Cut-blank means width times length of each piece, added together. A rounded corner or a card window still has to be bought before it is cut away, so the blank is the honest figure.

PatternPiecesSq inLeather at $14.97
Slim card holder325.3$2.63
Luggage tag323.8$2.47
Belt, size 36165.3$6.78
Passport cover365.0$6.75
Pocket notebook cover467.7$7.04
Bifold wallet575.1$7.81
AirTag key fob210.4$1.08
Business card case223.1$2.40
Cuff bracelet, 7 in wrist115.0$1.56
Dog collar, 16 in fit size327.9$2.90

The PDF repeats the table at a second rate of $20.00 a square foot, a round number for comparison and not a quoted price, plus a blank column for a maker’s own rate. Some patterns mix weights, a heavier outer with lighter pockets, and two weights rarely cost the same per foot. For a close figure, price each weight from its own side.

The AirTag fob uses about a dollar of leather. The most expensive pattern in the series, the wallet, uses less than eight.

Diagram of a leather side showing the usable area of 18.7 square feet inside a 22 square foot side

Everything that is not leather

Weaver’s guide then adds the rest. In its belt example: $3.00 of hardware, $0.25 of finishes, and $25.00 of labor, which it counts even for a one-person shop. Add the $11.23 of leather and the total cost is $39.48.

Labor is more than twice the hide in Weaver’s own numbers, and that is for a plain belt.

  • Hardware. Rivets, snaps, buckles, D-rings, priced per piece from the invoice.
  • Thread. Inches cut per item, from Bench Tool No. 1: Saddle Stitch Thread Length, divided by the inches on the spool and multiplied by the spool price.
  • Glue, dye, edge paint, wax. Small per item, easy to forget, real across a year.
  • Labor. Hours times a rate. Timing one build with a clock instead of a guess is the single most useful thing a maker can do with this sheet.
  • Overhead. Weaver’s method: estimate the year’s expenses (space, website, booth fees, tool upkeep, shipping supplies, marketing) and divide by the items made in that year.

Margin is not markup

The last line of the worksheet is where homemade price lists most often slip, over a single word.

Weaver sets a 40 percent margin, which it calls a common goal, and gets the price by dividing: $39.48 ÷ (1 − 0.40) = $65.80. A margin is a share of the selling price. Forty percent of $65.80 is $26.32, and that is what is left after the $39.48 of cost.

A 40 percent markup is a different animal. It multiplies cost by 1.4 and gives $55.27. On the same belt with the same costs that is $10.53 less, and the maker who meant margin and did markup has handed 40 percent of the intended profit to the customer without noticing. Dividing by 0.60 is the same as marking up by about 67 percent.

Weaver suggests going higher on one-of-a-kind hand-tooled pieces and lower, around 30 percent, for wholesale batches. The worksheet leaves the margin as a blank.

Bar chart of the leather cost in ten Marcellino NY patterns, from $1.08 for an AirTag fob to $7.81 for a bifold wallet

The case for pricing by materials

Not every working maker builds a price from labor up, and the other method has defenders.

On a leatherworker.net thread about pricing, a maker who says “I find myself always selling items too cheap” gets a reply built on materials. The replier totals raw materials and hardware and adds 25 percent for incidentals. He then multiplies by 3 for “an adequate profit on the materials alone,” multiplies that by 3 again for a starting base price, and adds another 20 percent for listings, advertising, processing fees and sales tax. An hourly rate comes in only for added customization. Worked through, that is materials times 13.5. The same reply also recommends checking what similar items sell for online.

The method is quick and it keeps a catalog consistent. Its behaviour shows when it runs beside Weaver’s on two patterns from the table, borrowing Weaver’s $25 labor line only to show the arithmetic and leaving hardware, thread and finish out of both.

ItemLeatherMaterials x 13.5Weaver, $25 labor, 40% margin
AirTag key fob$1.08about $15about $43
Bifold wallet$7.81about $105about $55

The two methods do not disagree by a fixed amount. They disagree by item. A materials multiple tracks the leather, so it charges little for a leather-light piece that still takes an hour of stitching, and a lot for a leather-heavy one whether or not the labor is there to match. A briefcase panel cut from a side, like the one in the video above, carries many times the wallet’s leather, and a multiple of 13.5 climbs with it.

Neither column is the right price. The worksheet puts both in front of the maker, which a price list built from a gut feeling never does.

Using the sheet across a catalog

One worksheet per item, filled once and kept, turns pricing into maintenance. When a side goes up in price, only line 1 changes and every item updates with it. Weaver recommends reviewing prices every few months as material costs move.

Two habits make the numbers honest. Time a whole build, including cutting, edge work and cleanup, not just the stitching. And measure blanks from the actual pattern, the way page 2 does for this series; a pattern drawn on cardboard, as in Making a Pattern From Cardboard, can be measured with a ruler in a minute.

Offcuts raise a fair question. An AirTag fob or a card holder often comes out of the scrap left after a bag or a belt, and it is tempting to call that leather free. It was not. It was paid for at the same rate as the panel beside it, and charging the full usable rate for it is what keeps a catalog of small items from quietly running at a loss. Whatever is truly unusable belongs in the waste percentage, which is where the weighing comes in.

Bar diagram comparing a 40 percent markup at $55.27 with a 40 percent margin at $65.80 on the same $39.48 cost

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 2

True Cost of a Leather Item: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · costing worksheet, leather area and cost of ten Marcellino NY patterns

Sources

You might also like


Leave a Reply