Rivet, Snap and Chicago Screw Sizes for Leather: A Post Length Chart

Leather Patterns / Rivet, Snap and Chicago Screw Sizes for Leather: A Post Length Chart
Rivet, Snap and Screw Post Lengths: Marcellino NY leather bench tools title card over a photograph of leather work on a workbench
0 Comments

Give a double-cap rivet a post that is too long and it does not set. It folds. The mallet comes down, the post bends sideways inside the cap like a nail hit off-centre, and the cap sits crooked on a strap that cost more than the whole bag of rivets. A post too short does the opposite and fails later, when the cap pops off in a customer’s hand.

Video: Installing Feet Rivets on a Handbag Case, from Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker on YouTube. Real bench footage of hardware going into a hand-dyed case; it does not demonstrate the chart.

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 4

Rivet, Snap and Screw Post Lengths: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · post length chart by stack, snap and copper rivet notes, true-size post gauge

Both mistakes come from the same missing number: the thickness of the stack the post has to pass through. The free Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 4: Rivet, Snap and Screw Post Lengths turns that number into a size, for double-cap rivets, snaps, Chicago screws and copper rivets, with a true-size gauge to check loose hardware against.

Measure the stack first

The stack is every layer the post goes through, pressed together the way it will sit when finished. A strap folded around a D-ring is two layers. A strap riveted to a bag panel with a lining is three. The weight stamped on the leather is only a starting point; a glue line or a lining adds thickness the label never mentions.

Measure the stack glued and pressed, the way it will be riveted, rather than adding up the weights stamped on each piece. Measure the pressed edge with a caliper if one is available. The PDF carries a true-size millimetre scale for a quick check, and ounces convert at roughly 1/64 inch, or 0.4 mm, per ounce, as covered in Leather Weight Explained.

One caution on conversions. Suppliers do not all use the same one. Buckleguy’s rivet chart lists 8 oz leather as 3.4 mm, where the 1/64 inch convention gives 3.2. Measure in millimetres and the disagreement stops mattering.

Double-cap rivets: the post stands proud

For double-cap rivets the suppliers agree on the principle and differ only on the amount. Tandy’s guide to setting hardware says there should be at least 1/16 inch of post standing above the leather “but no more than 1/8″.” Weaver’s listing for its #2200 double-cap rivets says the post should be 1/16 to 1/8 inch longer than the material. Buckleguy says roughly 2 mm through the far side, and its chart heading aims for 2 to 3 mm. Montana Leather adds 1/8 inch, or 3 mm, to the thickness.

In millimetres, that is a window of about 1.6 to 3.2 mm of post above the stack. Buckleguy’s 2 mm sits inside it. Montana’s 3 mm sits at the top.

StackPost neededTandy wide double-cap that fits
3 mm (about 8 oz)4.6 to 6.2 mmSmall (6 mm)
4 mm (about 10 oz)5.6 to 7.2 mmSmall (6 mm)
6 mm (about 15 oz)7.6 to 9.2 mmMedium (8.5 mm)
8 mm (about 20 oz)9.6 to 11.2 mmLarge (11 mm)
10 mm (about 25 oz)11.6 to 13.2 mmnone

Tandy’s wide double-cap rivets come in three post lengths: small 6 mm, medium 8.5 mm and large 11 mm. Weaver’s come in 1/4, 5/16 and 7/16 inch. The full chart in the PDF runs from 2 mm to 10 mm in half-millimetre steps up to 5, and it is blunt about the gaps. A 4.5 mm stack is too thick for Tandy’s small and too thin for its medium: the medium would stand 4 mm proud, past the 1/8 inch limit. That is a real gap in a three-size range, and the answer is a different maker’s post, a skived layer, or a test on scrap.

A dog collar shows how quickly that happens. A strap of 8 to 9 oz leather folded around a D-ring is two layers, roughly 6.4 to 7.2 mm. At the thin end, Tandy’s medium stands 2.1 mm proud and fits. At the thick end it stands only 1.3 mm, under Tandy’s 1/16 inch minimum, while the large would stand 3.8 mm, over the 1/8 inch maximum. The same collar strap from two different sides of leather can land on either side of the line, which is the case for measuring every batch instead of trusting the stamp.

Buckleguy publishes a finer ladder, twelve rows from a 5.6 mm post for leather under 7 oz up to a 15 mm post for 30 oz. Its chart is reprinted on page 1 of the PDF.

Cross-section diagrams of a double-cap rivet post too short, correct at 1.6 to 3.2 mm proud, and too long

Chicago screws: the post sits short

A Chicago screw does not get crushed. It clamps. PetHardware’s guide to choosing Chicago screws says that for leather, “which compresses when tightened,” the post should be 1 to 1.5 mm shorter than the measured thickness. Its worked example is two 2.5 mm layers, 5 mm in all, and a 4 mm post.

The logic holds up on the bench. A screw post as long as the stack bottoms out against the barrel before the leather is gripped, and the joint stays loose no matter how hard the screw is turned. A shorter post lets the head and barrel squeeze the leather before they meet. The same guide notes that webbing, which does not compress, takes a post the full thickness.

So a 5 mm stack wants a double-cap post of about 6.6 to 8.2 mm and a Chicago screw post of about 3.5 to 4 mm. The hole and the leather are the same, and the rules point in opposite directions; the PDF chart puts both columns side by side to make the point hard to miss. Setting Rivets and Chicago Screws Cleanly covers the setting itself.

Snaps and copper rivets

Snaps are sized by line, not by post length alone. Tandy’s line snaps listing says Line 20 “is ideal for 5-7 oz. (2-2.8 mm) leather while Line 24 is made for 8-10 oz. (3.2-4 mm) leather.” It lists a Line 20 post of 6 mm with an 11.11 mm cap, and a Line 24 post of 6.75 to 7.94 mm with a 14.29 mm cap. On a strap closure, each half of the snap goes through a single layer, so the leather weight on the listing is close to the stack. The cuff in the Marcellino NY cuff bracelet pattern is cut from 4 to 5 oz for the same reason.

Copper rivets and burrs work on a different principle again. The post is pushed through, the burr is pressed down over it, and the excess is cut off before the end is peened into a dome. Tandy’s hardware guide says to leave 1/8 inch of the post when cutting.

Not everyone agrees. On a leatherworker.net thread about copper rivets that would not hold, a moderator first wrote 3/16 inch, then corrected himself to 3/32, “just under 1/8″,” and added that 3/16 is usually too long. Another member warned that leaving too much means the rivet “may bend instead of dome.” Cut too short, the moderator wrote, and there is not enough material to hold the burr down. Between 3/32 and 1/8 inch is the range those sources share.

Diagram of a 5 mm leather stack with a rivet post standing proud and a Chicago screw post sitting short

Where the rules disagree

The tidy version is: rivets proud, screws short, copper about an eighth. The bench is messier, and a leatherworker.net thread on choosing rivet lengths shows how. Its original poster had heard both 1/16 and 1/8 inch and was happy with neither. One reply says the pressure-fit rivets that members call OTB rivets do best flush, not proud, and that a post sticking above the surface “will bend over, weakening the pressure fit”; the same member says Tandy-style rivets do need to stand up. Another says hammer-set rivets work anywhere from just poking through to 1/8 inch out. The thread never settles it.

The disagreement is mostly about rivet style rather than taste. A rivet whose cap is built to swallow extra post forgives a long one. A pressure-fit rivet with a tight collar does not. The chart follows the supplier numbers for the rivets it names, and for any other brand, the maker’s own listing beats every rule of thumb.

The cheapest test is still the best one. Set one rivet through a scrap of the real stack and cut it in half with a hacksaw, or pull it apart with pliers. The cross-section shows whether the post filled the cap or folded inside it.

Using the gauge

Page 2 of the PDF is a true-size gauge. It shows bars at the post lengths of the hardware above: Tandy small, medium and large, Weaver’s three, Tandy’s Line 20 and five steps from the Buckleguy ladder. Stand a loose rivet post or a stack of leather next to the line and compare. Print it at 100 percent and check the scale square first; a gauge printed at the wrong size is a confident liar.

The gauge is a check, not a micrometer. Near a size boundary, the scrap test above is the answer.

Chart of the double-cap rivet post length band against stack thickness with Tandy's 6, 8.5 and 11 mm posts

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 4

Rivet, Snap and Screw Post Lengths: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · post length chart by stack, snap and copper rivet notes, true-size post gauge

Sources

You might also like


Leave a Reply