A corner of navy leather lies on a sheet of sand-colored suede in the first photograph, and the raw edge of the leather shows its fibers. In the second and third photographs an olive green suede sits on the same sand-colored sheet. These are lining swatches, and the work is choosing which one goes inside a briefcase.
Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker on YouTube: Lining and Handles of the Lily Bag.

What the swatches show
The sand sheet reads as a neutral base. Against it the navy is nearly black, and the olive suede gets a slightly lighter, softer look because the nap catches the light. The napped surface shows on both the olive and the sand, and the edges of the olive suede are fuzzy where the cut leaves loose fibers.
A lining color is a decision that gets made once, at the bench, and then lives inside the bag for decades. A swatch next to the outer leather is how I check it.
Leather lining or suede
In my video answering a viewer question I laid out the choices. Matching leather lining adds weight and adds durability. Suede stays flexible. An unlined bag is the lightest and it dries easily when it gets wet. All of it is made to order, so the choice belongs to the person ordering.
I have also compared calf suede to cow suede in other videos. Calf suede is thinner and softer than cow split suede. On a navy bridle briefcase I have lined with Italian calf suede, and I said then that colors other than black are hard to source.


Why color is hard
Black suede is easy to find. In my video on suede lining I say plainly that colors other than black are hard to source, so a navy or an olive is not a casual choice.
I say in my videos that a bright suede lining opens a case up. An orange suede inside a briefcase of chocolate bridle pops when the flap opens.
Bridle or suede inside
For a longer comparison of leather lining against suede, the post on lining a case covers it: Lining a Case: Suede or Bridle. This post is about the colors, and the plain fact is that a lining is the surface the contents rub against every day.
Which suits a bag depends on what goes in it, and I make the call with the person ordering.
Sources
- Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker, Lining and Handles of the Lily Bag: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cf9WOLj4nQ8
- Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker, Explaining Suede Lining for A Marcellino Bridle Leather Briefcase (video could not be re-checked live): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgmNVVRRSOg




