Cardboard and folder-stock leather pattern pieces on a workbench with a steel ruler and knife.
| |

Making a Pattern From Cardboard

ByPeter Joeseph 'Briefcase Maker' Kalafatis

Cheap card is where most leather patterns start. The question is where they should stop.

A pattern made from cardboard is the cheapest insurance in leatherwork: a flattened cereal box standing between you and a ruined piece of hide. It costs almost nothing to cut, it shows you the shape in your hands before the knife touches leather, and when it is wrong you throw it out and cut another. The trouble is that not all cardboard behaves the same, and the stuff that is fine for a test can lie to you by the tenth trace. What follows is a buyer’s guide, cheapest first, to what makers actually cut patterns from, what each one costs you in accuracy, and the few tools that keep the lines honest.

Video: The Leather Element | Making Patterns From Scratch, from Weaver Leather Supply on YouTube.

Start on paper, then move to card

Paper is for thinking. Card is for tracing.

Hands tracing a cardboard leather pattern onto bridle leather with a scratch awl.

Tandy Leather’s guide to pattern making from concept to cut lays out the order most makers follow. Draw the idea, then draft it to scale on grid paper or cardstock, then build a test version and check that it folds, fits and lines up before anything goes near leather. It says plainly that “Some crafters even use cereal boxes or poster board.” That is not a compromise. For a first draft it is the right material.

Grid paper earns its place at the start because it lets you count. Square corners stay square, a pocket stays the width you meant, and you can erase. What paper can’t do is hold an edge. Run a knife or an awl around a paper pattern on stiff leather and it slides, curls, tears at the corner.

Kathleen Fasanella, writing on her sewn-products blog Fashion-Incubator, made the case against soft paper in a post titled Paper patterns, soft or hard?. She can’t stand how flimsy soft patterns are, and she argues that soft paper is too soft to give good lines. Her trade is cloth, not bridle. The point carries anyway: the thing you trace around has to be stiffer than the thing you trace onto, or the line goes where the paper goes.

My opinion: draft on paper, prove it on card, and never let a paper pattern near a knife.

Cereal boxes, file folders and poster board

The free stuff works. Know which job each one is good for.

Ask leatherworkers what they cut patterns from and the answers sound like a recycling bin. In a 2013 leatherworker.net thread, What do you use for a pattern, members named cola-case cardboard, cereal and treat boxes, wallpaper lining paper and, again and again, manila file folders. One member, olds cool, liked folders because they cut and fold easily and still resist tearing. Another, Jax, drafted on lining paper and glued the design to card once it worked.

Two years later a second thread, What do you use for pattern material, sorted the stock by how often a pattern gets used. JLSleather put plain paper at the bottom for patterns used rarely, card stock above that, and poster board for frequent but light use, with lacquered edges for extra strength. Several members simply said poster board and left it there.

Here is how I would sort the cheap end for a buyer. This part is my opinion, not a test result.

  • Cereal box card. Free, thin, easy to cut with scissors. Good for a test of shape. The printed side is slick and the fold lines from the box can sit right where you need a straight edge.
  • Manila file folders. Cheap, flat and even in thickness, and the fold is already a straight line if you plan around it. This is the same family as the oak tag sewing pattern makers use.
  • Poster board. Larger sheets, so a briefcase panel fits in one piece. Softer at the edge than folder stock, which is why the lacquer trick shows up.

The sewing world calls the hard version oak tag. Liesl Gibson of Oliver + S wrote a short post on what oak tag is, describing it as essentially the card stock of manila folders, and put the case simply: “Oak tag lasts longer than pattern paper.” She uses it for patterns that get traced many times. Leather patterns get traced harder than cloth ones, with an awl point dragged along the edge, so the argument only gets stronger at a leather bench.

When cardboard stops being enough

Every trace takes a little off the edge. Count the traces.

Macro of a worn cardboard pattern corner beside a crisp plastic template corner.

Fasanella makes the point that patterns degrade with use until you lose precision, and that is the whole problem with card. In my view, an awl point run around a folder edge, trace after trace, is exactly the kind of use she means: the corners round, the curves dent, and the shape wanders a hair at a time until two pieces that used to meet don’t.

The makers who cut the same shape often move to something harder. In that 2013 thread, Dwight praised bag stiffener from Tandy for patterns used often, saying it “surpasses cardboard like a Lamborghini passing a VW bug.” Others in the 2015 thread used rigid polystyrene sheet, vinyl flooring, and zinc or aluminum sheet for patterns that get cut around constantly.

A 2021 thread, Material for making templates, shows what each upgrade costs. The original poster, MtlBiker, found cardboard and mat board too flimsy and too easy to slice with a rotary cutter, Masonite good but harder to cut and more expensive, and acrylic expensive and prone to splinter when he cut it. One member, kgg, recommended HDPE sheet at least a quarter inch thick because it “cuts just like wood,” and warned that thinner sheet warps. Another suggested flexible plastic cutting boards, which MtlBiker said work but run too small for big patterns.

So the buying rule goes like this. One-off or first draft: card. A shape you will make a handful of times: folder stock or poster board, lacquered. A shape you will cut for years: plastic, hardboard or metal, and pay the extra to cut it once properly.

The tools that keep a pattern honest

A straight rule, a sharp knife, and a habit of cutting the line away.

None of these materials is any better than the line drawn on it. My advice, for what it is worth: buy a steel rule long enough to cross your biggest panel, because a short rule moved twice puts a kink in a long edge. Buy a sharp knife and change the blade before it drags, since a dull blade pushes card instead of cutting it and leaves a fuzzy edge you will trace around later.

Fasanella’s best piece of advice is small and easy to skip. Cut the line away. If you cut through the middle of a pencil line, the piece grows by half the width of that line, and if you copy the copy, it grows again. On a cloth pattern that adds up. On a briefcase it adds up to a gusset that won’t meet the panel.

Mark on the pattern everything the leather needs to know. Tandy’s guide says to mark holes, stitch lines and folds on the draft, and to trace onto leather with a scratch awl or a silver pen. It also says to keep finished patterns in a labeled folder or binder, which sounds fussy until you go looking for the gusset you cut last year and find three that look alike.

Clear stock earns a place too. In the 2013 thread a member named Sylvia used transparencies and sheet protectors for placing designs, since clear stock lets you put a pattern over the grain and see what sits under it. My opinion: that matters more on leather than on cloth. A hide isn’t uniform, and a pattern you can see through lets you dodge a scar.

Laying a cardboard pattern on the hide

The pattern says what shape. The hide says where.

Cardboard briefcase pattern pieces laid out on the bend of a vegetable-tanned leather hide before cutting.

Here a pattern starts to meet the real thing, and cardboard has one advantage over everything else: you can move it around the hide for free. For a briefcase I use only the bend, the butt part of the hide, where the fiber is tightest. The belly goes in the trash. The shoulder goes to small parts. A stack of card pieces lets you play the layout before committing, the same thinking behind cutting a briefcase out of a bridle leather bend.

I inspect every hide when it comes in, looking for defects, and a flaw nobody else would notice for years still bothers me, because my name goes on the case. The pattern is where that inspection turns into a decision. Lay the pieces, look under them, shift them, and read the bend for what the card is sitting on.

Thickness is the other thing a flat pattern can’t tell you. My gussets run thinner than my panels so the case bends at the sides without creasing on the face. Two pieces can share an outline on paper and need different leather under them, so write the thickness on the card.

Then test the shape. Tandy’s guide says to assemble a test version with tape or clips and check the folds and the fit. Dwight, in the 2013 thread, made the honest point that paper and cardboard don’t show how a piece will hang, and he used cloth-backed vinyl when drape mattered. Card stands up stiff where bridle bends in a curve. A cardboard mockup tells you the size. It lies about the fold.

Where I part company with the pattern

I work mostly by rule and by eye. That is a confession, not advice.

Now the turn. I just wrote a buyer’s guide to pattern stock, and I don’t keep a drawer full of briefcase patterns. I work with rulers and by eye, more like a sculptor than a draftsman, and a lot of my layout goes straight onto the leather. One of my videos is literally called “Scratched Out briefcase Pattern on brown Sedgwick English Bridle Leather,” on my channel, and another is Hand Cutting Bridle Leather Briefcase Pattern.

Part of that is the work. A commissioned case is built for one buyer, which is the whole idea behind commissioning a bag, so a fixed template would be wrong for the next customer anyway. On The Maker page I say every case is made by one person, shaped, stitched and finished, and the eye that does the shaping is doing the job a pattern would do.

The other part is plainer. A beginner’s eye hasn’t put in the hours, and pretending it has is how good leather gets cut short. In my view, a cardboard pattern is the eye you borrow until your own shows up.

And the eye has limits even after it shows up. A strap, a loop, a handle wrap: shapes that repeat. My opinion is that for those a stiff pattern beats any eye, mine included, because an eye drifts over a long day and a piece of card doesn’t.

Which leaves me selling cardboard to beginners while cutting my own cases freehand. The card is cheaper than the argument.

12-Inch Stainless Steel Metal Ruler with Non-Slip Cork Backing: A 12-inch stainless steel ruler with a non-slip cork back. See it on Amazon (affiliate link).

WORKPRO 18mm Retractable Utility Knife: An 18 mm retractable utility knife with snap-off blades. See it on Amazon (affiliate link).

General Tools Scratch Awl with Hardwood Handle: A scratch awl with a hardwood handle. See it on Amazon (affiliate link).

54 Pcs Leather Marking Pen Set: A set of marking pens for leather and fabric. See it on Amazon (affiliate link).

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Sources

You Might Also Like

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply