How Much Thread for a Saddle Stitch: A Formula and a Printable Chart

Leather Patterns / How Much Thread for a Saddle Stitch: A Formula and a Printable Chart
Saddle Stitch Thread Length: Marcellino NY leather bench tools title card over a photograph of leather work on a workbench
0 Comments

Two inches from the end of a seam, the needle comes through and the thread stops. There is nothing left to tie off, nothing to backstitch with, and twenty holes of good work hang on a tail too short to hold. Every hand-stitcher has done it once. Most do it twice, because the rule they were given was a number pulled from someone else’s leather.

Video: Hand Stitching Saddle Stitching an American Harness Leather Briefcase, from Marcellino NY Briefcase Maker on YouTube. Real bench footage of a long saddle-stitched seam; it does not demonstrate the chart.

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 1

Saddle Stitch Thread Length: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · multiplier chart, short-seam table, worksheet for three seams

The rules people pass around disagree. A maker on one leatherworker.net thread cuts four times the seam length “so as not to struggle towards the end.” On another thread, one maker multiplies by 6 for two layers of 8 to 9 oz, a second relies on 5x for 5 to 8 oz leather and bumps to 6x for seams under 6 inches, and a third uses 5x for leather around 8 oz. An online saddle stitch calculator says guides usually land between 3.5x and 5x.

They are all right, for their own leather. The printable Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 1: Saddle Stitch Thread Length shows why, with a chart that gives the number for any stack and any iron.

The arithmetic behind the rules of thumb

A saddle stitch is one thread with a needle on each end. Both needles go through every hole. Between two holes, each strand passes once through the full thickness of the leather and once along a face of the work, to the next hole.

So for every hole, each strand uses one pitch (the hole spacing) plus one stack (the total thickness of every layer sewn). Two strands double it. Per unit of seam, the thread used is:

Thread per unit of seam = 2 × (1 + stack ÷ pitch)

None of this is new. In 2008 a member named RandyScott posted a formula on leatherworker.net: thread per inch equals “((leather thickness X Stitches per inch) X 2) + 2”. Stitches per inch is one over the pitch, so his formula and the one above are the same line written two ways. His worked example was a sheath of two 8 oz pieces at 5 stitches per inch: 4.5 inches of thread for every inch of seam.

What the formula makes plain is that the multiplier is not a constant. It moves with two things only: how thick the stack is, and how far apart the holes are.

Reading the multiplier chart

The chart on page 1 of the PDF runs stack thickness down the side, from 2 mm to 12 mm, and iron pitch across the top, from 2.7 mm to 6 mm. Pitches follow the common European iron sizes, matched to stitches per inch from the Amy Roke iron table at Rocky Mountain Leather Supply: 3.85 mm is 6.6 spi, 3.38 mm is 7.5, 3.0 mm is 8.5, 2.7 mm is 9.4. Ounces are converted at 1/64 inch per ounce, the convention covered in Leather Weight Explained.

JobStackIronMultiplier
Card holder, two layers of 3-4 ozabout 3 mm3.85 mm3.6x
Wallet, three thin layers at a pocketabout 4 mm3.38 mm4.4x
Belt lap, two layers of 7-8 ozabout 6 mm4 mm5.0x
Sheath or holster, two layers of 8-9 ozabout 6.8 mm5 spi (5.08 mm)4.7x
Briefcase gusset seam in heavy bridleabout 8 mm5 mm5.2x

Thin small goods sit near 3.5x to 4x. Heavy holster and harness work climbs past 5x. The maker who swears by 4x is probably sewing wallets, and the one who swears by 6x is sewing heavy holster or harness work with long tails. Neither is wrong, and neither should hand the other their number.

Dense stitching costs thread too, and the chart shows it plainly. Hold the stack at 4 mm and move from a 5 mm iron to a 2.7 mm iron: the multiplier goes from 3.6x to 5.0x. Finer stitching means more trips through the leather per inch, and every trip pays the full thickness.

Diagram of a saddle stitch: each strand crosses the leather stack and runs one pitch along a face between holes

Why a short seam needs more than a long one

The chart gives thread for the seam itself. A real cut also needs a working tail at each needle, the length that hangs from the leather to the needle and lets a hand pull the last stitches tight. RandyScott’s 2008 example used 12 inches at each end. In an earlier post on the same question, from 2007 he added 12 inches per side plus 6 to lock the thread to the needles, for 142 inches on a 28 inch seam.

Tails are a fixed cost. They do not care how long the seam is.

Page 1 of the PDF has a table that runs the numbers with 12 inch tails. On a 3.2 mm stack with a 3.85 mm iron, a 3 inch seam takes 35 inches of thread, which is 11.7 times the seam. The same stitching on a 48 inch seam takes 200 inches, or 4.2 times, with the same leather, the same iron and the same hands.

That is the explanation for the maker who uses 5x but bumps to 6x under 6 inches. The short seam does not use more thread per stitch. The tails just weigh more against it. On a long seam the tails nearly vanish into the total, which is why a belt maker and a card-holder maker can quote different rules and both be telling the truth about their own bench.

Using the bench card

Page 2 of the PDF is a worksheet with room for three seams. Each one runs the same seven lines:

  • A. Seam length.
  • B. Stack thickness, all layers pressed together, in millimetres.
  • C. Iron pitch in millimetres. For an iron sold in stitches per inch, divide 25.4 by the spi.
  • D. Multiplier, 2 × (1 + B ÷ C).
  • E. Seam thread, A × D.
  • F. Tails, twice the working length.
  • G. The cut, E + F, rounded up.

A worked case: a 10 inch pocket seam through two layers of 4 oz (about 3.2 mm) with a 3.38 mm iron. The multiplier is 2 × (1 + 3.2 ÷ 3.38), which is 3.9. The seam takes 39 inches. Tails of 10 inches each add 20. Cut 59 inches, round to 60.

Measuring the stack matters more than the iron. Glue lines, a lining or a folded edge add thickness that a label weight does not show. Press the layers together and measure the edge with a caliper or a fine rule.

Line chart of the thread multiplier rising with stack thickness for 2.7, 3.85 and 5 mm irons

Where the formula comes up short

The formula is a floor. It treats the thread as a line with no thickness that turns perfect right angles at every hole, and real thread is neither.

Diamond irons cut a slanted hole, so each pass through the leather is a little longer than the stack. Waxed thread wraps around itself as it crosses in the hole. Tension takes up more length on a hard pull than on a gentle one, and RandyScott himself warned that results vary with how tight the stitches are pulled, the thread’s weight and ply, and how even the leather is. A backstitch at each end, the usual finish described in Finishing a Saddle Stitch, runs a few holes twice and needs its own allowance.

So the honest advice is to cut a little past the number. How much past is a matter of habit. A margin of about 10 percent is a sensible starting point for small goods, not a measured figure; heavy work pulled hard may want more.

There is a case against the whole exercise, and it deserves its say. Plenty of makers never calculate anything. One poster on the formula thread says the thread “should be no more than the double length of your arm,” which is a limit, not a formula, and RandyScott, citing Al Stohlman’s book on hand sewing, recommends an arm span of thread, which he puts at about 69 inches. A long seam can also be split, ending one thread and starting another, rather than dragging ten feet of waxed thread through a hundred holes. Bench experience beats arithmetic once a maker has sewn the same bag forty times.

The chart is for the other times: a new item, a new leather, a new iron, an expensive spool, a seam where a join in the middle would show. Or the first job with a premium braided thread like Ritza 25 Tiger, sold by the spool, where offcuts add up over a year.

Thread size is a separate question

The chart answers how much thread. It does not answer which thread. Thickness and hole size go together: thread too thick for the iron jams in the hole, thread too thin looks lost in it. That pairing is covered in What Thread Size Goes With What Leather, and waxing is covered in Waxing Thread Before You Stitch.

Thread thickness also nudges the length a little. A fat thread fills more of the hole and travels a slightly longer path around the stack, so a heavy thread on a fine iron uses more than the formula says. The margin is there to absorb it.

Bar chart showing a 3 inch seam needs 11.7 times its length in thread and a 48 inch seam 4.2 times

Marcellino NY Bench Tool No. 1

Saddle Stitch Thread Length: Free Printable PDF

⬇ DOWNLOAD THE BENCH TOOL (PDF)

2 pages · US Letter, print at 100% · multiplier chart, short-seam table, worksheet for three seams

Sources

You might also like


Leave a Reply